| Platinum | Teak and Charlie's Jersey Girl Pizza |
| Gold | Red Oak Kitchen |
| Silver | Chaotic Wings, Pizza, Burgers & More |
| Bronze | Press Cafe |
| Top Pick | Bubba's 33 |
| Top Pick | Cicis |
| Top Pick | Mi Piaci Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Papa Johns Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Hut |
| Fazoli's | |
| Mr Gatti's Pizza |